Ian Grant Spong
Ian Grant Spong's blog
 1038stars  |   33readers
View profile|View all posts| Follow this blog
Violent Christians?
||March 11, 2008|504 reads
 

To add a comment to "Violent Christians?"
Ian Grant Spong
March 12, 2008
You are certainly right to look at the words "until now" and ask the question as to whether or not that meant ONLY until John. So the natural question is whether or not that violence would also continue. I believe the answer comes in Jesus' next sentence, when he said that men of violence "take" it by force, not "took" it by force. In fact violence was done to Jesus on the cross, martyrs down through history, and continues with the greatest martyrdom in all history in our times.

The verb in the Greek is in the present active sense, not the past tense. As such, I believe it still applied when Jesus said it and as a principle still applies today.
Ian Grant Spong
March 12, 2008
As far as Christianity not existing at that time, I suppose that depends on your definition of Christianity. If you define Christianity as the Church and church history beginning with Pentecost, then of course, you would be right. However, if you define Christianity as beginning with and being founded upon the teachings of the Christ, as I do, then we are definitely talking about Christ-ianity here, rather than merely the Church.
Ian Grant Spong
March 13, 2008
I quite agree with much of what you say. However, you are speaking of the transition to the New Covenant and the birth of the Church, not Christianity in its entirety. If I took your definition, then NOTHING that Jesus taught would be relevant as teaching for the Christian church. Yet, when Jesus was about to suffer the cross, he taught his disciples to teach what he had taught them. As such, the TEACHINGS of Christianity after the cross are very much centered on what Jesus taught them BEFORE the cross, and as recorded in the mostly pre-cross Gospels.
Ian Grant Spong
March 13, 2008
I too find it simple. Christ taught it and the disciples were required to teach what Jesus taught. End of story. Perhaps we'll just pass on the rest of this discussion for the sake of peace. Blessings!