Kathy
Kathy 's blog
 1790stars  |   178readers
View profile|View all posts| Follow this blog
Blog Etiquette
||May 16, 2007|2182 reads
 

To add a comment to "Blog Etiquette"
Mike n Laura
May 16, 2007

Kathy, I may check back later, but at first glance all looks fine. ~mike

Julia Bennett Burch
May 16, 2007
Kathy, I agree with Mike. The fact is, most of it sounds like common sense.
Deb Rockwell
May 16, 2007
I think it all sounds good.
Carol Suh
May 16, 2007
Star!
Mike McCorquodale
May 16, 2007
It sounds good to me, Kathy.
Mike
Normally Norm
May 16, 2007

The only one that I don't necessarily agree with is the 20 line one.  But I admit I like to keep conversation on a topic in one spot.  And since there isn't a trackback *whistle* feature, following all of the conversation otherwise isn't the easiest. 

Kathy
May 16, 2007
Thanks for the comments, and Norm, thanks for the helpful suggestion.  Of course 20 lines is an arbitrary number, but I chose it, because, including paragraph spacing, 20 lines is about a filled screen.  (This entire blog is only 27 lines.)  Any comment longer than that (on someone else's blog) I often scan over without a careful reading, whereas if it were divided into shorter comments, I would read it more carefully.  Just me maybe.  Thanks, Norm!  
Dennis Howe
May 16, 2007
I would also think about how to suggest that tome is everything. Our tone comes across, so if there's a question about tone, it's good to write out our comment in a word processor program and hold overnight, then review and post. This also works well for e-mails. I've also found that if it's an area that Im passionate about I run my thoughts through others to see if it's neccessary for me to even comment. In one recent case doing that caused me to realise that my comment would refuel a burning out fire!
Sue
May 16, 2007

The only thing I take issue with is "Do not use someone else's blog for the purpose of promoting your own

You know I am only kidding, girlfriend!  You covered what we do in your next sentence:

"It is appropriate to link to your own blog if you have a related blog that adds something to the subject."  AKA Blog Pluggin'

 
Ha Ha Only Joking

Normally Norm
May 16, 2007

Sorry.  I wasn't really arguing with 20 or 27 or 52.  Or to put it another way, I wasn't suggesting a correct number of lines.  And I agree with your statement that anything really long may be skimmed.  But that tends to be true whether it's a comment OR the blog itself. :)

If I'm interested in a topic, I will read the blog & comments.  Honestly there are a number of blogs where I'm more interested in the comments than the blog itself.  And when it comes down to it, I feel it's more respectful to the person who started the conversation to comment on it on their blog than to try to take the business elsewhere ("My" blog).

And FWIW I like the way Gmail threads mail.  I like the way a bulletin board has everyone commenting on the same topic in the same thread.   I like tabs in Firefox (as opened to a new browser window for everything).  Although I'm occasionally guilty of it, I don't like links that force a new browser window.

Sue
May 16, 2007
Sorry Kathy!  But the temptation was just too great!
Kathy
May 16, 2007
Sue, you are too funny!  You got 6 plugs into one comment and didn't even get near 20 lines!  We love you, plugs and all! 

Dennis, you make a very good point.  Tone is hard to measure when we're writing, because the reader doesn't see our facial expressions, our body language, or our eyes.  Your suggestion to wait a while before posting is a good one!

Norm, you make some really good points.  And the one about being more respectful to keep the long posts on the original blog is one I'm pondering.  I think I agree with you, but what about the commenter who posts several of his own complete blogs as comments on yours?

You're shaping my thinking.  This is why I posted this blog, to get a broader "MyChurch" view of blogging etiquette to share with newcomers, rather than just my own.  These are good.  Thanks!
Normally Norm
May 17, 2007

Well that depends.  Is it on topic and does it add value?  If the answer is yes I hardly see the issue.  And unless I'm a special case, the original poster can delete blog comments (although if we're talking etiquette I would think a warning or a copy of the original in an "e-mail" to the person posting the comment would be good).  From other places I've been, there are the occasional problems but usually it's someone having a bad day and these rules wouldn't apply anyways. :)

And if we're talking about my blog, I would personally prefer 2 long 25 liners* that discuss the point at hand from the same person than 50 (or even 5) "Me Too" lines from 50 different people.  No that doesn't mean I'll delete "Me too", just that many times I'm looking to discuss something. 

* - I add length only to contrast 50 lines vs. 50 lines.  Again I'm not trying to suggest a length limit.   

Kathy
May 17, 2007
Thanks, Norm.  I'm making some minor changes as I listen to the comments here, and hope to hear form others on this issue.  Maybe length doesn't belong in etiquette rules at all?
RuthAnn Wilson
May 18, 2007
At risk of just adding "me too" I think this is good courtesy and an important reminder.
Virginia Gill
May 22, 2007
Kathy,

I take the Google mission statement as my personal blogging rule "Don't be evil." LOL  Sounds simplistic I know but at least here where just below the comment box it tells us to encourage one another we should do so.  THINK YOUR TOPIC THROUGH before you post!  If it going to be the beginning of a wildfire, why are you posting it?  What do you hope to accomplish?  If it's just for the sake of making people angry try something else.  If you truly believe what you are writing needs to be said, be prepaired to defend it. 

You've mentioned similar things but mostly in view of posting to someone else's blog.  I think it applies to your own as well.

So far I haven't seen anyone doing that here, eventually it my happen though.  Reember too that these days employers (as well as colleges young people) are doing searches for blogs of people that are interviewing.  Know that what you write here (anywhere online)may impact your life forever.

Virginia
Margaret  Galbraith
September 11, 2007
  
    KATHY
    THANKYOU FOR THIS BLOG, AS A NEWCOMER I FIND IT VERY HELPFUL!.
    I WISH I HAD FOUND IT EARLIER......
    Margaret
Kathy
September 11, 2007
Thanks, Bestemor!  Virginia, good additions here!  Margaret, welcome to MyChurch!  I'm glad the blog was helpful to you!
Kathy
October 10, 2007
Another important issue:   If you post something that is not origninal, even if you don't know the author, list your source (Say for example:  "Forwarded to me by a friend.  I don't know who wrote it.")
Kathy
December 23, 2007
Mike n Laura posted a blog that adds some very good suggestions about commenting on blogs:  http://www.mychurch.org/blog/114496/Really-I-didnt-mean-it-that-way